There comes a time in a reviewers “career” (let’s call it that, even though this is just for fun), I think most of us start doubting the ratings we’re giving. I’ve had SO many discussions about how I rate, why I rate one book with 5 stars and another with 2. The more books I read the more I realize that 40/100 books can’t be 5-stars. There has to be at least something that makes a book feel “less” than others.
When I first started to write reviews I read a lot of weird things. But I always compared the books to the feelings The Hunger Games gave me back when I was 14, laying in my bed for four days straight, devouring everything about the books. The “wiser” I got the more I realized that you can’t rate every book based on another book, it doesn’t work like that – because a non-fiction book won’t be anything like The Hunger Games, so therefore I kind of “gave up” that way of rating. So now I kind of take it on the feelings I get as I read the book.
A five star book for me, is a book that I can’t lay down, it’s a book I almost read from cover to cover. It’s a book with complex characters and a story I’ll never forget. It’s a book that I want to immediately re-read, and it’s a book that I’ll recommend to EVERYONE. Since about May of 2016 I’ve only rated five books 3 or lower, and out of 32 books, 24 of them has been a 4 or higher.
So have I gone soft? I don’t think so. The books I read are mostly books I know are highly rated. I rarely read books that has ratings below 3.8 on Goodreads, and since I mostly read Fantasy or Science Fiction (YA of course), which are my two favorite genres, I think it kind of says something about the books I generally read and why they are rated the way they are. I rarely read non-fiction because I often find them boring, and therefore, whenever I read non-fiction they rarely get anything above a “3”, and all though that’s more of a personal opinion; I also think that reviews are personal.
A review is a personal opinion of the book, a personal indication to how good a book is. If I really like YA sci-fi with a dash of romance, the YA sci-fi will probably get a higher rating than, let’s say a biography. So, have I gone soft? Neh, I think I’ve just been incredibly lucky to be able to actually read some of the best books out there. But I am going to be tougher. I’ve decided that I need to be in order to give you guys the best possible reviews I can.
There can be no more difficult job than to judge someone else’s creativity. I don’t know how you do it, but I applaud your courage! And no matter how you rate a book, you are providing the rest of us with information about it so we can decide if we want to read it. Keep on keepin’ on!
LikeLike
Thank you Fred! It means the world to hear you say that! I see it as a privilege to be able to write about books to be honest, and for people to actually see it and read it means the world to me.
LikeLike